INTRO Athletic fatty

nukatide

Explorer
Joined
Mar 16, 2026
Messages
12
Reaction score
3
Location
Vancouver wa
I'm really pumped. Being a fat guy who's active has always been my thing. Working out? Never an issue. Dieting? That's where everything fell apart. Honestly, I did strongman-style training, but my eating matched that lifestyle too. I'd run marathons and similar things hoping to shed pounds, yet all I did was build muscle. When I tried eating clean, I'd end up consuming huge amounts of lean protein and veggies, battling constant hunger, and in the end I'd always give in... I've joined this new community to learn and add what I can.
 
If you haven't given this a shot yet: put plenty of butter (and/or cream) on your meat and veggies, and chances are good you'll feel full while eating less -- plus you may drop some weight as a bonus. That's how it worked for me. By plenty of butter I mean as much as you can handle, right up to the point where you clearly feel you've had enough. Could be 100 gr, 200gr per day, or even more. Should heated butter be an issue for you, have it at room temperature instead; it brings great flavor to meat and vegetables alike. Just keep starches limited or cut them out. Welcome to the forum!
 
Appreciate it, man! It genuinely means a lot that you'd take the time to give me some encouragement. For me, weight loss has been an all-out trench war — I keep gaining and losing ground, and the battles I've lost outnumber the lbs I've dropped. I stuck with each of these for at least 3 months: keto, vegan, vegan-keto, carnivore, Daniel fast, and slim fast. I gave fasting a shot for as long as 20 days, and dry fasting a couple days at a time. It honestly feels like trench warfare — I lose some lbs, put it all back on and then some. You might have pointed out something I overlooked during keto, which is how important it is to get good amounts of fats. I'd heard that before, but I was still hung up on cal in/cal out, so I'd go light on the fats. Just wondering out of curiosity — would you suggest pairing high fats with glp products? Some randos claimed carbs somehow activates the reta, so I'm curious whether you know anything about that?
 
Haha I know that struggle, do some digging and you'll figure it out. I've never had this much BBQ chicken breast with season all — it preserves your existing muscle mass as the fat melts off.
 
nukatide said:

Appreciate it, man! It genuinely means a lot that you'd take the time to give me some encouragement. For me, weight loss has been an all-out trench war — I keep gaining and losing ground, and the battles I've lost outnumber the lbs I've dropped. I stuck with each of these for at least 3 months: keto, vegan, vegan-keto, carnivore, Daniel fast, and slim fast. I gave fasting a shot for as long as 20 days, and dry fasting a couple days at a time. It honestly feels like trench warfare — I lose some lbs, put it all back on and then some. You might have pointed out something I overlooked during keto, which is how important it is to get good amounts of fats. I'd heard that before, but I was still hung up on cal in/cal out, so I'd go light on the fats. Just wondering out of curiosity — would you suggest pairing high fats with glp products? Some randos claimed carbs somehow activates the reta, so I'm curious whether you know anything about that?
Apologies — your question slipped past me because no notification came through. Clicking Reply is the way to go, then alerts actually reach people.

So, a seasoned diet fighter, huh?

As for what you asked: glp wasn't part of my approach. My view is that plenty of folks can manage through dietary changes alone (granted, that's no small feat!), and high-fat keto in particular tends to be both healthier and easier to keep up over time (barring any specific conditions you might have). Getting sufficient fat matters enormously — around 70% of total calories — while keeping protein from creeping too high. Results can shift depending on which fats you choose, too. Cutting out dairy (butter stays!) or spices, or every form of sugar and sweetener, works better for some. Experimentation is the only way to know. My own win came from nudging lowish-carb into keto: capping rice at 25gr and replacing it with low carb vegetables. If it were feasible I'd drop rice entirely, yet it isn't so straightforward — without some starch my gut struggles to digest fat, and carbs lend a hand.

One more point: fat intake needs to be adequate, and so does protein — in short, eating enough, full stop. Finding your sweet spot requires trial and error. Both sufficient energy and sufficient protein are needed (without going beyond that! 🙂 ). Starving yourself over a long stretch is a bad idea and can stir up all sorts of problems. Learning to heed your body's signals takes time...
 
Hello! Another athletic fatty checking in. Once my collegiate sports days ended, my workouts did too—but my college-athlete appetite stuck around. Talk about a perfect storm! These days I'm 51, 6'1" and 320, doing everything I can to rewind the clock....we'll find out.
 
Flexon said:

nukatide said:

Appreciate it, man! It genuinely means a lot that you'd take the time to give me some encouragement. For me, weight loss has been an all-out trench war — I keep gaining and losing ground, and the battles I've lost outnumber the lbs I've dropped. I stuck with each of these for at least 3 months: keto, vegan, vegan-keto, carnivore, Daniel fast, and slim fast. I gave fasting a shot for as long as 20 days, and dry fasting a couple days at a time. It honestly feels like trench warfare — I lose some lbs, put it all back on and then some. You might have pointed out something I overlooked during keto, which is how important it is to get good amounts of fats. I'd heard that before, but I was still hung up on cal in/cal out, so I'd go light on the fats. Just wondering out of curiosity — would you suggest pairing high fats with glp products? Some randos claimed carbs somehow activates the reta, so I'm curious whether you know anything about that?
Apologies — your question slipped past me because no notification came through. Clicking Reply is the way to go, then alerts actually reach people.

So, a seasoned diet fighter, huh?

As for what you asked: glp wasn't part of my approach. My view is that plenty of folks can manage through dietary changes alone (granted, that's no small feat!), and high-fat keto in particular tends to be both healthier and easier to keep up over time (barring any specific conditions you might have). Getting sufficient fat matters enormously — around 70% of total calories — while keeping protein from creeping too high. Results can shift depending on which fats you choose, too. Cutting out dairy (butter stays!) or spices, or every form of sugar and sweetener, works better for some. Experimentation is the only way to know. My own win came from nudging lowish-carb into keto: capping rice at 25gr and replacing it with low carb vegetables. If it were feasible I'd drop rice entirely, yet it isn't so straightforward — without some starch my gut struggles to digest fat, and carbs lend a hand.

One more point: fat intake needs to be adequate, and so does protein — in short, eating enough, full stop. Finding your sweet spot requires trial and error. Both sufficient energy and sufficient protein are needed (without going beyond that! 🙂 ). Starving yourself over a long stretch is a bad idea and can stir up all sorts of problems. Learning to heed your body's signals takes time...
Thanks, buddy! I've gone back to a keto approach and started including a couple tbsp of butter, and my energy levels have really improved. I cooked cauliflower rice in butter to make fried rice, and honestly it tastes just like my usual fried rice (though my palate isn't very sensitive). The texture comes out a little firmer, but I'm really enjoying it!! Appreciate the awesome suggestions!
 
Welcome aboard! That description fits me to a T: an athletic fatty. I hit the gym nearly every day of the week and have finished 15 half marathons, yet the number on the scale refuses to cooperate. My hope is that digging deeper into reta will finally be the turning point I need to push the scale down into overweight range for the first time in what feels like forever.
 
Back
Top