How much load comes off the joints after weight loss?

AllCourtTENNIS said:


"each unit of weight loss was related to a reduction in knee joint loads by a factor of 2.2."

Click to expand...

You're dealing with 2 separate "units" here, so to speak — 2 distinct yet connected aspects of your knee.

Let me put on my physics nerd glasses for a moment; I'll try to tie it back to things you can actually touch and feel.

Mass is mass, weight is mass. That's a fundamental physics property and pretty simple. Pick up a bowling ball — it has mass, and it's likely somewhat heavy.

Loading is a different beast: it's force divided by area. You may recall Einstein's F=ma => here the a stands for gravity (acceleration due to gravity). The crucial point is that m is mass, so when mass drops, force drops.

Load =

Force = mass x gravity

———. ——

Area. Area


(That's as deep as the physics goes, I promise — hang in there with me!)

Suppose you're placing a gallon of milk down: the amount of "push" — force — that the bottom surface experiences is uniform across the whole face. Now balance that same jug on a pencil, and you've got identical mass or force concentrated over a far smaller area doing the supporting. So the /loading/ shifts even though the jug itself hasn't changed. What changed is the area that "feels the weight."

Physics lesson over. 🙃😝

Our knees aren't so different. While walking, your weight rests on 1 knee at a time. If you're running, you're probably airborne or at minimum experiencing more vertical motion than walking. My waist measures … 30-some inches around, maybe? Perhaps 40? The bones in my knee certainly aren't that size. Milk-jug-sized waist (and weight) meets drink-coaster-sized knees.

Is that 2.2x figure accurate? I can't say for certain off the top of my head, but it sounds plausible.

With love, your friendly neighborhood enginerd who adores running even though I'm limited right now.
 
Back
Top