tubby said:
Minkster said:
Has anyone else seen their cholesterol numbers decline while taking Reta? I've used Reta for 6 months and dropped 25lbs, with about 15lbs more to lose. My HDL fell by over 10pts, putting it too low, while my LDL & nonHDL rose by a couple points and were already elevated. This is completely opposite to what I anticipated. The only positive changes were in triglycerides, fasting glucose, and A1c.
For LDL or TG, a swing of just a few points (assuming the units are mg/dL) carries essentially no significance. Such values fluctuate naturally day to day, and likely even within the same day.
HDL is a different story. Its range tends to be tighter, and it matters considerably more, so a 10 mg/dL decrease is worth paying attention to. Is it possible you've reduced your saturated fat intake? A lot of people get convinced they should keep it as low as possible, and their cholesterol readings end up suffering for it. An illustration of what a diet centered on maximizing saturated fat can achieve (think butter, dairy, and coconut oil supplying most of the fat) is shown here.
My own HDL had already been at a decent level (I think eating plenty of cheese played a role), but when I moved to a low-carb/keto style of eating and lost weight along with it, the numbers improved substantially: HDL climbed a lot and TG fell a lot across roughly 18 months. I'm leaving out a lab result from the middle of that stretch (one where everything looked better) because it was drawn while I was still losing weight; the two results I'm showing both came from times when my weight was fairly steady, which makes for a fairer comparison.
There has been an overly strong emphasis on lowering LDL instead of raising HDL, yet when it comes to cardiovascular health, a meaningful rise in HDL is worth far more than a small drop in LDL.